Hey there, fellow sales leaders – it’s time to discuss the responsibility where sales leader mistakes surface the most: hiring.
Let’s have a real talk about hiring, something we all know is make or break for our teams. You’ve been there, right? You need rockstar reps to crush those sales goals, but too often, the process goes sideways. I’ve been in the trenches for years, coaching leaders just like you, and I’ve seen the same three big sales leader mistakes pop up again and again. Fix these, and you’ll build a team that doesn’t just survive but thrives. I’ll walk you through each one with some practical fixes, drawing from what I’ve learned works across industries. Let’s dive in!
Sales Leader Mistake #1: Your Job Ad Is a Hot Mess
Alright, let’s start with the first slip-up: your job description is a vague mess.
You throw up something like “experienced rep needed” or “must know the industry” and call it a day. Then what happens? A flood of applications rolls in, and half the candidates don’t even fit your team’s vibe. You spend hours interviewing people who are way off track. Sound familiar? That’s because your ad isn’t telling the right story.
Here’s the fix: update that job description and make it crystal clear. Lay out the daily grind, what they’ll actually do, like making calls, nurturing leads, or prepping proposals. Paint a picture of your team, how you work together, the energy in the room. Toss in the skills you need, like relationship building or tech savvy, and sprinkle in your company values, like hustle or integrity. This isn’t just about attracting bodies, it’s about setting the stage so the right folks walk through the door. Think of it as your first chance to connect with them, clear communication from the get-go.
Our VP of Recruiting and Talent Strategy, Tabitha Cavanagh likes to say this succinctly: tell the truth. This entire truth should emulate in your job ad.
Take it from me, I’ve seen leaders turn this around. One guy I worked with had a generic post that got him a bunch of duds. We rewrote it to say, “Looking for a rep who thrives on building client partnerships, with daily tasks like follow ups and strategy sessions. We value teamwork and a growth mindset.” Boom, applications shifted. He started getting reps who clicked with his team’s focus on long term wins. Data backs this up too, Harvard Business Review says 80% of turnover comes from bad hires, but a sharp, honest job ad can slash that risk by 25%.
So, grab a coffee, pull up your current ad, and spend 30 minutes making it real. Ask your team what they’d want to see, then post it fresh on LinkedIn or your site. You’ll see better candidates roll in, trust me.
Sales Leader Mistake #2: You’ve Got No Onboarding Plan, You’re Winging It
Okay, let’s say you nail the hire, congrats, you’ve got a superstar!
But if you hand them a laptop and say, “Good luck, figure it out,” you’re setting them up to fail.
Great talent has options. If they feel lost in those first few weeks, no direction, no support, they’ll jump ship to a company that’s got their act together. I’ve watched reps walk out the door within a month because they were left to fend for themselves. It’s a shame, because they had the potential to shine.
Here’s how to fix it: build a solid onboarding plan. Map out the first 90 days like a roadmap. Assign a mentor to show them the ropes. Schedule training sessions to cover your product, tools, and processes. Set clear milestones, like booking their first call by week two or leading a demo by month one. Throw in team meetings so they get the feel of the crew. This isn’t just about throwing them in, it’s about helping them grow into the role fast.
Think about it this way, it’s like giving them a head start to learn and fit in. Pair them with a mentor for one on ones, where they can shadow calls and get real time feedback. Run a weekly check in to review progress, maybe they nailed a pitch, or maybe they’re tripping over objections. Offer tips, like, “Slow down and ask about their biggest pain point.” It turns raw talent into a producer. Plus, it builds that team vibe, host a lunch or a quick meet and greet to show them where they belong. One company I guided was losing 30% of new hires in the first month. They added a buddy system and skill workshops, and retention shot up to 90%. That’s the power of a plan.
The stats don’t lie either. Gallup found strong onboarding lifts productivity by 70%, while weak plans lead to 20% of newbies bailing within 45 days. So, grab a notebook and sketch it out. Day one: intros and tour. Week one: basic training. Month one: hands on work with feedback. Test it with your next hire. It’ll keep them engaged and contributing sooner, way better than watching them walk away.
And if you’re onboarding plan is non-existent, it may be time to revaluate your entire sales process as this is a critical piece to the engine.
Sales Leader Mistake #3: You’re Chasing the Wrong Things
Now, this is a big one, you’re looking at the wrong stuff when you hire. Too many of you hunt for industry experts or reps with killer sales skills, thinking that’s the ticket. But here’s the truth: their attributes beat all of that.
Self-motivation. Honesty. Integrity. Drive. Grit. These are the things that stick. People either have them or they don’t. Tactical skills? You can teach those. Industry knowledge? You can share it. But these core competencies that we like to bucket into their Will to Sell and Sales DNA are the fuel that keeps reps going long term.
Here’s why this matters: you can train a newbie on your product in a week, but you can’t teach drive. Take a motivated rep with no experience, coach them on your sales process, and they’ll outpace a veteran who lacks fire. I’ve seen it happen. One leader I worked with hired a guy with deep industry know-how. The rep knew the lingo but didn’t push through rejections, deals stalled. They switched gears, brought on a hungry newcomer, and spent time coaching skills. That rep hit 120% of quota in six months. Attributes like grit shine through in tough times.
How do you spot them?
Dig in interviews. Ask, “Tell me about a time you failed. What did you do next?” Listen for that spark, did they bounce back or give up? Try, “Share a moment you bent rules. Why?” Check for integrity. Probe answers. A rep who says, “I worked late to fix a mistake” shows drive. One who shrugs off accountability? Red flag. Gallup data backs this, 89% of failed hires flop due to attitude gaps. Attributes predict 75% of performance. Skills account for less.
Or use our Sales Candidate DNA Test, which is able to measure for these core competencies and bucket them into the candidate’s Will To Sell and Sales DNA.
Putting It All Together
These sales leader mistakes connect. A clear job ad pulls in candidates with the right attributes. A solid onboarding plan helps them grow into those roles. Focusing on attributes ensures they fit your team long term. Avoid them, and your hiring wins. Your team grows stronger. Revenue climbs. Turnover drops.
One last thing, I’ve been where you are. I’ve coached leaders through these exact issues. It works when you commit. Start with that job ad today. Sketch that onboarding plan this week. Test those interview questions with your next hire. You’ll feel the difference.
Ready to nail your next hire? Watch the recording of our latest Sales Leader Council webinar, “How to Hire Your Next Top Seller.” We dig into strategies to dodge these pitfalls and build your dream team. Let’s get you the talent you deserve!
Continued reading:
